Lily is a toy produced by Playtime Co., who will likely be a secondary antagonist in Chapter 5: Broken Things.

Miss Delight.

Baldi, whose full name is Baldi Baldimore, is the titular main antagonist of the Baldi's Basics series, hence his name, and the titular main protagonist of the Baldimore comic series

Monika (モニカ) is a main character and the poster girl of Doki Doki Literature Club!. She is the President and Founding Member of the Literature Club

Natsuki (ナツキ) is a main character of Doki Doki Literature Club!. She is the fourth member of the Literature Club, and a character whom the player can write poems for

Baby Anya!!!

Sunky is the main playable character from the parody of Sonic the Hedgehog called "Sunky The Game", made by LooneyDude

The Good Guy doll is a highly sought-after, fictional toy created by Play Pals

Theodore Masters Peterson, also known by his nickname the Neighbor, is an unemployed and ordinary neighbor

Arwen is the leader of the Fallen angel cats, he is the most powerful angel of heaven. Their enemy is Bosa, the king of the Shih Tzu demons

Yuri (ユリ) is a main character of Doki Doki Literature Club!. She is the third member of the Literature Club, and a character whom the player can write poems for

Baby Talking Tattletail, or simply Tattletail, is the titular deuteragonist of Tattletail. The toy brand was developed by Waygetter Electronics

Anya (Also known as Anya sawyer and Experiment 2007) is another one of Doctor Harley Sawyers experiments that was brought into the Poppy Playtime universe. She’s originally from SpyxFamily

The Projectionist is a cyborg-like ink creature that is one of the many inhabitants of the Cycle and the inky reincarnation of Joey Drew Studios's lead projectionist Norman Polk. He is the tertiary antagonist of Chapter 3 and Chapter 4 of Bendy and the Ink Machine, and the secondary antagonist of Boris and the Dark Survival. He also returns as a minor supporting character in Bendy and the Dark Revival.

Tom is an alternative counterpart of Boris the Wolf and the cartoon form of Thomas Connor who appeared at the end of Chapter 4 and the start of Chapter 5 from Bendy and the Ink Machine along with Allison Angel.

Charley is a cartoon character from the Bendy cartoons by Joey Drew Studios and the leader of the Butcher Gang, as well as one of the main antagonists of the in-universe Bendy franchise

Allison Angel, typically referred to as Alice, is the ink recreation of Allison Pendle and an alternative form of the original Alice Angel who appeared in the latter two chapters of Bendy and the Ink Machine and throughout Bendy and the Dark Revival, along with her protector Tom.

That’s a lot of kids

Maria Mikhailovna Kujou or nicknamed Masha is one of the two deuteragonists (alongside Yuki Suou) of the romance comedy manga, and light novel serie Alya Sometimes Hides Her Feelings in Russian. She is a student at Seirei Private Academy who is well as one of the most popular girls alongside Chisaki Sarashina. She is the elder sister of Alisa Mikhailovna Kujou. Like her younger sister, she is half-Japanese and half-Russian

Cuphead is the titular main protagonist of the video game of the same name. Cuphead is Mugman's carefree older fraternal twin brother and like the rest of his family, lives on Inkwell Isle. He is usually played by the first player and as a result, was the default character for Player One before the update in April 2019, after which the first player can choose whether to play as him or Mugman